TY - JOUR
T1 - A method to evaluate REE-HFSE mineralised provinces by value creation potential, and an example of application
T2 - Gardar REE-HFSE province, Greenland
AU - Banks, Graham J.
AU - Olsen, Símun D.
AU - Gusak, Antonio
N1 - Funding Information:
We thank three anonymous reviewers for their valuable efforts, suggestions and comments. We also thank Francis Wall (University of Exeter), Julie Hollis (Ministry of Mineral Resources and Labour, Government of Greenland), Adrian Finch (University of St Andrews), Oliver Kreuzer (Corporate Geoscience Group), Jakob Kløve Keiding (Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland), Sam Weatherley, and Kathryn Goodenough (British Geological Survey) for their comments and suggestions that improved the manuscript. G.J.B. thanks many former Maersk Oil, Fugro Robertson and WesternZagros Resources colleagues for their conversations and teamwork on province and basin screening, favourability, uncertainty, mapping geological risk, and the cost-value profile of regional-scale evaluations. This research, and the costs to prepare this document for open access publication, was part of the HiTech AlkCarb project, under the European Union Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme, grant agreement number [ 689909 ].
Funding Information:
We thank three anonymous reviewers for their valuable efforts, suggestions and comments. We also thank Francis Wall (University of Exeter), Julie Hollis (Ministry of Mineral Resources and Labour, Government of Greenland), Adrian Finch (University of St Andrews), Oliver Kreuzer (Corporate Geoscience Group), Jakob Kl?ve Keiding (Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland), Sam Weatherley, and Kathryn Goodenough (British Geological Survey) for their comments and suggestions that improved the manuscript. G.J.B. thanks many former Maersk Oil, Fugro Robertson and WesternZagros Resources colleagues for their conversations and teamwork on province and basin screening, favourability, uncertainty, mapping geological risk, and the cost-value profile of regional-scale evaluations. This research, and the costs to prepare this document for open access publication, was part of the HiTech AlkCarb project, under the European Union Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme, grant agreement number [689909].
Publisher Copyright:
© 2020 China University of Geosciences (Beijing) and Peking University
PY - 2020/11
Y1 - 2020/11
N2 - The rare earth elements and high-field-strength elements (REE-HFSE) exploration sector conducts most evaluations at deposit and smaller scales. It is not evident how the sector performs a preceding exploration stage—rating and prioritising REE-HFSE mineralised provinces—to determine which provinces are prospective enough to warrant investment. Here we present an objective, repeatable, low-cost method to screen any REE-HFSE province, as a foundation for district-scale investigations or asset evaluations. It is original for REE-HFSE screening, and adapted from regional scale copper, cobalt and petroleum exploration, and CO2 storage, screening methods. It is centred upon a mineralised province's favourability for potential value creation, and to identify: (a) its main information gaps; (b) its weakest links; (c) its exploration maturity and remaining potential category; (d) how it compares against other REE-HFSE provinces; and (e) if further investigation is justified. This method incorporates geoscience, strategy, economic and socio-environmental factors in a way that is understandable and directly usable across stakeholder groups. The workflow is systematic, yet flexible enough to accommodate organisation-specific criteria, and usable for other commodities. It provides the platform to build a global REE-HFSE province map and database consistently across national boundaries and organisations. Categories for the extent of province exploration maturity and remaining mineral potential are proposed. We illustrate the applicability of these methods using the Gardar REE-HFSE Province (GRHP) of south Greenland. We conclude that it is a moderate size, frontier province that is currently of questionable favourability for value creation. To move GRHP into a positive favourability class, its current weak links need strengthening by research, government policy and industry stakeholders: evaluate the mineral system; integrate all information geospatially and place it in the public domain; help the region improve some community health and safety issues; convert some mineral resources into an Ore Reserves category; commence mining and sales production.
AB - The rare earth elements and high-field-strength elements (REE-HFSE) exploration sector conducts most evaluations at deposit and smaller scales. It is not evident how the sector performs a preceding exploration stage—rating and prioritising REE-HFSE mineralised provinces—to determine which provinces are prospective enough to warrant investment. Here we present an objective, repeatable, low-cost method to screen any REE-HFSE province, as a foundation for district-scale investigations or asset evaluations. It is original for REE-HFSE screening, and adapted from regional scale copper, cobalt and petroleum exploration, and CO2 storage, screening methods. It is centred upon a mineralised province's favourability for potential value creation, and to identify: (a) its main information gaps; (b) its weakest links; (c) its exploration maturity and remaining potential category; (d) how it compares against other REE-HFSE provinces; and (e) if further investigation is justified. This method incorporates geoscience, strategy, economic and socio-environmental factors in a way that is understandable and directly usable across stakeholder groups. The workflow is systematic, yet flexible enough to accommodate organisation-specific criteria, and usable for other commodities. It provides the platform to build a global REE-HFSE province map and database consistently across national boundaries and organisations. Categories for the extent of province exploration maturity and remaining mineral potential are proposed. We illustrate the applicability of these methods using the Gardar REE-HFSE Province (GRHP) of south Greenland. We conclude that it is a moderate size, frontier province that is currently of questionable favourability for value creation. To move GRHP into a positive favourability class, its current weak links need strengthening by research, government policy and industry stakeholders: evaluate the mineral system; integrate all information geospatially and place it in the public domain; help the region improve some community health and safety issues; convert some mineral resources into an Ore Reserves category; commence mining and sales production.
KW - Favourability
KW - HFSE
KW - Province
KW - REE
KW - Screening
KW - Value
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85090341794&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.gsf.2020.05.019
DO - 10.1016/j.gsf.2020.05.019
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85090341794
SN - 1674-9871
VL - 11
SP - 2141
EP - 2156
JO - Geoscience Frontiers
JF - Geoscience Frontiers
IS - 6
ER -